Flat tyre — part 3 (buckled rim)

Flat tyre – part 3

Following on from part 2.

Tesla contacted us to say that the slow leak in our tyre is due to a buckled rim.

I had hoped for some small tyre repair, costing next to nothing. So the quote for a new wheel at $1300 was a shock 😳.

As you can see in the photo, it’s buckled on the inside edge, which explains why I couldn’t find the cause when the wheel was attached to the car. I’m glad, in this case, I didn’t try and find a hole to repair on the side of the road somewhere.

My passengers now mention that they recall us hitting a large pothole, while travelling south from Cessnock to Gerringong, but we can’t recall where.

I’ll be away road tripping, so at least I get to add 2000km to the loan wheel before I return it 😉.

Links

41 comments

  1. Roads around Australia are in extremely poor condition.
    Check your wheel alignment as well
    3

    Reply

  2. I find it hard to believe that the rim can be buckled and cracked yet the tyre is fine.
    2

    Reply

    1. Daniel Warring if you look closer, There is some pinch type damage to the sidewall around the damage to the wheel. It’s surprising that the tyre didn’t destroy itself with the damage to the wheel though.
      31

      Reply

    2. Daniel Warring it's not and should absolutely be replaced too.
      If it was a Khumo it would have broken on the spot

      Reply

      1. Daniel Warring via Facebook ↗
        Kind of my point even though Tesla say tyre is fine. I would be changing it

        Reply

  3. Ouch. Big pothole somewhere.
    21

    Reply

    1. Jason Munro Tesla wheels are quite soft too.
      1

      Reply

      1. Martin Harrington why I specifically didn’t option the larger wheels. Where I live they would not have survived long.
        1

        Reply

  4. The rim can be repaired to keep as a spare https://www.wheelsolutions.com.au/ are near Tesla Richmond, I have used them do a great job.
    1

    Reply

  5. Sorry to hear, but just as I expected. Quite a common occurrence unfortunately.
    Twenty five or so years ago my father had both alloy rims on one side buckled on his Peugeot.
    The rims were repaired.
    Then, a few weeks later he did the same thing on the other side of the car, both rims. The damage was worse, and the rims were deemed unrepairable, so he needed two new factory rims at great expense.

    (In my opinion, ultra low profile rims are a very bad idea for all sorts of reasons. We have 18” rims on our 2019 M3P and 19” on our Juniper Y. I will not fit larger rims under any circumstances, period.)
    2

    Reply

    1. David Nye Yeah, I prefer the thicker tyres, smaller rims. The Launch Edition only came with 20” rims, unfortunately. I even asked Tesla if they could swap them, prior to delivery.
      21

      Reply

      1. I actually thought the Y launch edition had 20” wheels.
        Am I wrong?
        (Our LR Y has 19”, and the Performance has 21”. If I owned a performance, the very first thing I’d do is buy aftermarket smaller rims and sell the originals. Lots of people like them for the looks.)
        2

        Reply

      2. David Nye You’re right. My mistake. My Launch Edition has 20” rims. I’ve corrected it.

        If anyone wants mine, for the looks, I’d be happy to swap for 19” black.
        1

        Reply

      3. Something else you could consider if you don’t find somebody wanting a direct swap is 18” aftermarket rims from someone like Cybermetals.
        However of course it is a big outlay as you then need new tyres as well, … though of course would have four wheels and tyres to sell.
        I’m not sure what I’d do in your situation, maybe keep hoping for a swap?
        (However if I had a Performance with 21” rims I’d definitely do it!)
        1

        Reply

    2. David Nye do you like the 19 inch wheels compared to the 18 ? Ie is there a much great risk of damage to the rim ?

      Reply

      1. Robert Martin it certainly makes a difference having 1/2" extra flex in the tire. Not only less chance of damage but a more compliant ride.
        2

        Reply

  6. they crack pretty easily too.. i found a good used rim on FBMP for $50.
    1

    Reply

  7. Pauline Smith I’m with Don. The potholes are outrageous. Ouch.
    2

    Reply

  8. There’s many wheel repair shops around. I had a minute crack in my model S performance wheel with a slow leak like yours. Took it to the shop and it was fixed inside a day. $190. Never leaked after that.
    3

    Reply

  9. Ouch an expensive repair I worry about my low profile tyres on my Y performance
    2

    Reply

  10. This happened to me once with a previous non-Tesla. On Christmas Day of all day. With the boot loaded up with gifts and luggage as we were travelling to the south coast. On the Clyde Mountain with nowhere to pull over! The only saving grace was it was a non-alloy wheel snd I found someone who could do some percussive repairs.
    21

    Reply

  11. And again, this is why I carry a spare wheel. No way I'm paying Tesla $1300! I've got spares at home that I got off people who bought new wheels within 50 kms of buying their cars. $500 including tyres
    1

    Reply

    1. Kieran Pradeep Do you have one to fit mine? 😉
      1

      Reply

      1. Tesla Tripping 19 inch Y? I've got 2 for the series before yours which would fit (I bought a set of 4 as a spare set; cheaper than tyres alone).
        1

        Reply

    2. Kieran Pradeep mine are 20” (I mistakenly wrote 19” before).

      Reply

  12. Wow you didn't feel it when you hit it?

    Dumb question but if it was that big wouldn't FSD avoid it? I'm sure I've seen videos of cars avoiding pot holes, maybe it's only in the US 🤷🏼‍♀️
    1

    Reply

    1. Kylie Gilroy need v14 for pothole avoidance unfortunately
      2

      Reply

      1. Vincent Lui ahh ok thanks, that's why I've only seen US videos
        2

        Reply

      2. Vincent Lui What's wrong don't your eyes work or have people become to reliant on technology these days .
        1

        Reply

    2. Kylie Gilroy I must have felt it, like the passengers did. I just couldn’t recall it specifically.

      Unfortunately, our FSD doesn’t avoid potholes. It’s one of the three most common reasons for my interventions at the moment.
      1

      Reply

  13. Dan PT via Facebook ↗
    I wish I opted for smaller wheels and tyres for my 22my. I opted for 20” 😫
    1

    Reply

  14. This happened to us also but 2 wheels were buckled, so changed tyres and rims went to 19” from the 20”
    2

    Reply

    1. Samantha Woodward Did you buy them new, outright? I just got a quote for $7k from Tesla to do that 😬

      Reply

    2. We brought some second hand one from fb . The seller was up grading and we were down grading lol
      3

      Reply

  15. Wheel Repairs Melbourne https://share.google/Js1ewkLN1KR80L3A3

    Will straighten and fix it.

    Reply

  16. I bought a whole set of rims for 1200, actually I bought 5 so 1500..

    Reply

    1. Robert Manser Nice! Where from?

      Reply

      1. Tesla Tripping CyberMetals rims and went an inch smaller which has improved ride and handling.

        Reply

  17. Ouch, that sucks. I feel better now about my decision to order my Model Y with the ugly 19” rims… I was on the fence as the 20s look so much better.
    1

    Reply

  18. This happened to us but two rims - middle of the night and didn’t see the join in a country road bridge that had opened up. Insurance did cover the replacement costs FYI.

    Reply

  19. I had sane issue. I got mine straightened at a wheel shop for $150
    1

    Reply

Leave a comment