Does size matter? Tesla Model Y vs YL.

A six-seat Tesla Model YL turned up at the Worldwide Light Show meet — parked right next to our red Y, captain's chairs and all. Tesla had loaned it to Garry from TOCA (Tesla Owners Club of Australia), Victoria for a few days to bring along to events like this one, so we got to climb all over it before the show started!

Likes:

  • The captain's chair armrests in the second row — cleaner than the bench in our Y.
  • The sub-trunk lid that magnetically clings to the back of the seat when you flip it up. Lovely bit of engineering.
  • V2L! We would love to have vehicle to load on our EV, like most models now have. If only we could cook food on our induction cooktop, while camping, from the massive battery in the car. The Tesla Model Y L and new Model Y Performance both have V2L.

Unsure:

  • Six seats vs our five. The third row is tight — elevated floor, very little leg room. I had to stick a leg out into the aisle just to half-fit. Climbing in and out takes some practice.
  • The captain's-chair armrest is cool, but I'm not sure it beats the pull-down armrest with cup holders in ours.
  • It's bigger. That gives more room on the inside, but takes more room on the road, and a bit of range.
  • 681km WLTP range is impressive, but it's an NMC battery and slightly less efficient (km per kWh) than our car.

For four people, our Model Y still wins. For five, I'd probably still pick ours. Six? Now we're talking — but that's a narrow use case for us.

Then we shut its doors, walked back to TRIPNG, and watched both cars dance to Lord of the Rings in time with a few thousand Teslas worldwide.

If you're considering one — what'd swing it for you?

Related Posts

11 comments

  1. Related Posts:

    Same evening — the worldwide light show:
    https://www.facebook.com/tesla.tripping/posts/10589799303…

    Earlier comparison — the Kia EV6 against our Model Y:
    https://www.facebook.com/tesla.tripping/posts/74729606823…

    Where ours came from:
    https://www.facebook.com/tesla.tripping/posts/75986454364…

    Reply

  2. pity Tesla's so reluctant with V2L
    1

    Reply

    1. Mark West I know, right! So handy to have for camping, blackouts or on site tools.

      Reply

  3. Tyson Finn via Facebook ↗
    I own a model yl and i can sit in the rear comfortably. Im 6ft2
    21

    Reply

    1. Tyson Finn Great! I shall therefore just conclude that I am uncoordinated 😉. Do you have to detach your outside leg?
      1

      Reply

      1. Tyson Finn via Facebook ↗
        Tesla Tripping nope
        1

        Reply

  4. Stuart Jones via Facebook ↗
    The YL is certainly an impressive car but unless you have family of 3 or 4 children I’m not sure why you would buy it. Our second car is a ford Everest for towing that has 7 seats and it’s more awkward to get into the back seats also less legroom than the M YL
    2

    Reply

  5. Unfollow button please.
    100% a biased post only because you own a 5-seater.
    I have 5-seater and 6-seater
    Both are great and there is no comparison.
    But I will have 6 seater anytime only coz I can fit any my mates or family anytime I want that extra seat does matter at the end of the day.

    Reply

  6. Abhi Singh via Facebook ↗
    Which looked better? Black/grey or red
    2

    Reply

    1. Abhi Singh I prefer our red. But several liked the grey Model YL.

      Reply

  7. Aaron Chandler via Facebook ↗
    The adaptive suspension
    The range
    The six seats
    The space
    The performance
    The seats
    2

    Reply

Leave a comment